The Charleston, explained: right, over, left (and why everyone groans)

How the Charleston works in American mahjong, pass by pass, plus the blind pass, the courtesy pass and what to actually give away.

By Bam Boulevard · · 4 min read

Ask a table of mahjong players what they love about the American game and someone will say "the Charleston." Ask what slows down a new player and the same person will say "the Charleston."

It's a tile swap that happens before anyone takes a turn. You get rid of stuff you don't want, you receive stuff someone else didn't want, and somehow your hand usually gets better. It's a little like a white elephant gift exchange, if the gifts were bamboo.

The short version

Everyone passes three tiles at a time, face down, in this order:

  1. Right
  2. Across
  3. Left

That's the first Charleston, and every game has one.

Then, if all four players agree, there's a second Charleston going the other way:

  1. Left
  2. Across
  3. Right

Any one player can stop the second Charleston, no reason needed. Then comes the optional courtesy pass, which we'll get to.

A lot of tables chant "right, over, left" out loud the first time through. It feels silly for about two games and then you'll catch yourself doing it alone.

How a pass actually works

Pick three tiles from your rack and push them face down toward the player you're passing to. Wait until everyone has passed before you pick up what you received. Then look at your new tiles, rethink your hand, and choose your next three.

Two rules matter more than the rest:

  • You always pass exactly three tiles on each of the six passes. Not two. Not four.
  • You can never pass a joker. Not in the Charleston, not in the courtesy pass, not ever.

The blind pass

Here's the trick that makes experienced players grin. On the last pass of each Charleston (the first left and the final right), you're allowed to pass tiles you haven't looked at.

Say it's the left pass and you only have one tile you want to get rid of. You can take one or two of the tiles being passed to you on that same round, without looking at them, and send them straight on to the left along with your one bad tile. You still pass three total. People call this a blind pass, or "stealing."

Why would you ever do that? Because sometimes everything in your rack is useful and you'd rather not break up a good start. Blind passing lets you keep your hand together and gamble on someone else's leftovers.

The courtesy pass

After the Charleston, you and the player across from you can trade zero to three tiles. You each say how many you want to swap, and you both go with the lower number. If they say three and you say one, you each pass one. If anyone says zero, you skip it.

It's called a courtesy pass because it's optional and nobody is obligated, but it's very common, and it's a small, friendly last chance to fix a hand.

What to pass

This is where strategy starts. A few things we believe pretty firmly:

Decide on a direction early. Before your first pass, glance at the card and pick two or three hands your tiles lean toward. Passing randomly to "see what happens" mostly just hands your neighbors good tiles.

Pass what you can spare, not just what's ugly. Lonely flowers and single winds feel like obvious throwaways, but a lot of hands use them. Look at the card before you toss them.

Watch what comes back. If you keep getting passed Dots, someone near you probably isn't playing Dots. That's useful.

Don't hoard. New players often try to keep everything "just in case" and end up with a rack full of maybes. A hand that wants everything wins nothing. Commit a little.

Stopping the second Charleston

Any player can call off the second Charleston, and nobody has to explain why. Sometimes your hand is already in good shape and you don't want to break it up. That's a fine reason. Being polite about it is nice. Just say "I'll stop" before anyone starts picking out tiles.

Every group has a player who stops it every single game. You'll know who it is by the second week.

Common Charleston mistakes

  • Passing a joker. It happens more than you'd think when you're grabbing tiles fast. Count your three, check for jokers, then push.
  • Picking up too early. Wait until everyone has passed, or the table gets confused about whose tiles are whose.
  • Forgetting the direction. "Right, over, left. Left, over, right." Say it out loud. Nobody minds.
  • Blind passing on the wrong round. It's only on the last pass of each Charleston: the first left and the final right.

Practice it before game night

The Charleston feels slow at first because you're doing it at the speed of thought. Once you've done twenty of them it takes a couple of minutes.

You can run through a guided Charleston against the computer in our Play Mahjong practice table. It walks you through each pass so you can learn the order without four people watching you count to three.

Once the Charleston clicks, the next thing to learn is how jokers work, since they're the tiles you're not allowed to pass and the ones everyone wants.

Your weekly

The Boulevard

One fun email a week: a tip you can use at your next game, a puzzle, and new tables on the Mahjong Map.

Join the Boulevard. It's free. Unsubscribe anytime.